Why to not believe the Nova Scotia government on extent and impacts of clear cutting

Another bit of unbiased truth northeast of Halifax Airport. View Mimicing Natural Disturbances in Nova Scotia. Click on image for time series.

In an op-ed today (Sat, Jan 14, 2017), forest ecologist Donna Crossland states the concerns about clearcutting clearly and simply. She begins with two satellite images showing a startling level of clearcutting in the Cloud Lake area between 2001 and 2014. “The images accompanying this article portray an unbiased truth”, says Crossland. She cites many other pieces of evidence to support her case that “DNR has allowed the liquidation of too much of our forest.”

Crossland also bemoans the lack of transparency. “We know from harvest records that large, mature trees once dominated our landscapes. We’ve tried to obtain age class information from DNR, but it is not readily accessible. There is a lack of government transparency. While volunteering on the forest panel during the Natural Resources Strategy, I was bluntly informed that I didn’t need to know such things; that all the required information was on their website. Halifax Examiner journalist Linda Pannozzo has written extensively about the transparency issue, most recently about the “disappearing forest age class data”.
Continue reading

Posted in clearcuts, events, Letters&Editorials, NSDNR, Show Us the Science | Leave a comment

Bob Bancroft talks about Firewood, Wildlife and the Well Managed Forest on Saturday Jan 21, 2017

Bob Bancroft, well known advocate for wildlife in Nova Scotia and outspoken critic of industrial forestry practices in the Maritimes will be giving this talk at the Tantallon Library, Tantallon, Nova Scotia at 2 pm on Saturday January 21, 2017.

The presentation is sponsored by the Nova Scotia Firewood Club. “Bob is a well-known, popular guest on CBC Radio Noon. He was an extension (education) biologist, editor, and fisheries biologist before leaving the provincial civil service in 1999. Currently president of Nature Nova Scotia, Bob led a scientific panel in 2009-2010 that was asked by government to make recommendations for a new forest strategy
Read more in The Masthead News.
Continue reading

Posted in clearcuts, Conservation, events, Wildlife | Leave a comment

Forest fungi in the news again

An earlier post ( Oct 24, 2016: How trees talk to each other) highlighted research by a B.C. scientist showing how trees communicate via mycorrhizal (fungal) networks in the soil, even allowing older trees to nurture younger, shaded trees.

A recent article in the Globe and Mail, Scientists identify the real king of the forest: fungus (Jan 12, 2017), describes research by other B.C. scientists who found that the types of mycorrhiza fungi that trees associate with can influence whether the trees tend to grow in pure stands or mixtures. This was “a large-scale study involving 55 species and 550 populations of North American trees” (including sites in Nova Scotia) published in the prestigious journal Science .

It seems we are still only scratching the surface when it comes to understanding what goes on in the soil.


shopify analytics ecommerce

Posted in Natural History, Show Us the Science | Leave a comment

Hard times for wood pellet industry in Nova Scotia

Photo by Tom Bruton

Photo by Tom Bruton

“It’s déjà vu all over again in Middle Musquodoboit as former wood pellet plant operator Scotia Atlantic Biomass Company’s assets go up for grabs…The wood pellet industry as a whole is hurting because a long-anticipated European growth in demand for pellets simply fizzled out.” View CH 10 Jan 2017. It has been known for some time that Viridis Energy was looking for a buyer.


Posted in Biomass, Climate Change, Economics | Leave a comment

Protecting Nova Scotia’s true boreal forest

True boreal forest in Nova Scotia is special; “borealized” Acadian forest is not.

Maps show the occurrence of the boreal forest in the Maritimes (above, modified from Mosseler et al., 2003) and all of Canada (below, from Wikipedia).

We go to great efforts in Nova Scotia to “borealize” our native mixed Acadian forest by clearcutting on short rotations and use of herbicide to create even-aged, conifer-dominated forests. However, true boreal forest is restricted to the cool Cape Breton Highlands, and a narrow strip along our Atlantic and Fundy shores that is cooled by the Labrador current and by upwelling of cold water in the Bay of Fundy.

The 100 Islands Legacy Campaign, a conservation effort recently launched by the Nova Scotia Nature Trust, highlights the presence of essentially undisturbed boreal forest on islands off of the eastern shore of Nova Scotia; a number have been protected by the provincial government.

The largest chunk of boreal forest in Nova Scotia lies in northern Cape Breton. There, coniferous boreal forest dominated by balsam fir occurs on the more exposed plateau areas while mixed Acadian forest penetrates the area in deep, sheltered valleys. On the parts of the plateau subject to most extreme weather, the closed forest gives way to “taiga*”, an open barrens with stunted black spruce and low shrubs analogous to the taiga or “Forest Barrens” lying between the northern margins of the boreal forest and the tundra in the Canadian north; it is “a piece of the Arctic in Cape Breton“.
*The term “taiga” or “Taige” is variously applied to the larger Boreal Forest/Forest Barrens biome, or to just the Forest Barrens component (as in Parks Canada use of the term to describe the Northern Cape Breton ecosystems).
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, Conservation, Mi'kmaq, Natural History, NSDNR, Parks & Protected Areas, Show Us the Science, Wildlife | Leave a comment

Editorials and letters about forestry in Nova Scotia, continued..7Jan017

logsIn Saturday’s CH, two gentlemen with firm roots in forestry add their voices to the ongoing discussion of forestry issues in the media.

Tom Miller of Green Hill, a woodlot owner and operator for 42 years, responds to an earlier letter in which it was suggested that the public leave behind “the spinning of romantic tales of horses, manual saws and long winters spent in the woods” to let the professionals do their technologically sophisticated work. Says Tom Miller: “Ms. Fuller alone has a romantic notion that anyone wants to be using manual bucksaws in the woods today. But she does the horse a disservice. After 42 years in the woods, three-quarters of it spent as a “chopper”, I can say that horse-logging is the hands-down best way to spend a day in the “lumber woods”. Watching a well-trained draft animal help get the job done is a rare treat. The “horse-logging woods” are also a rare treat today. You need big trees to make that work and there are few big tree “chances” left.
Continue reading

Posted in clearcuts, Economics, Letters&Editorials, Private Woodlots, Show Us the Science | Leave a comment

Readings from Maine: Mitch Lansky on managing forests to increase carbon capture and reduce carbon emissions

I suspect that virtually every Nova Scotian who has visited Maine (and that’s most of us) knows exactly where this photo was taken. There’s a lot of carbon sequestration going on here.

There is a lot of talk in the forest industry about using more wood in construction as a means of creating more markets and capturing more carbon to reduce climate warming. Unlike the claim that using forest biomass to generate energy can reduce carbon emission, there appears to be no controversy about the claim that using more wood in construction would be good for carbon capture.

If promoting wood for construction puts a higher premium on older trees/shade tolerant species, it could also help to reinvigorate the Acadian forest, thereby benefitting native biodiversity and ecosystem services. We could have our cake and eat it too. We don’t when our forestry is focussed on “low value wood” (early successional species harvested on short rotations) for pulp and paper, bioenergy, bioplastics and the like.

Mitch Lansky, who I would describe as a Maine elder and is well known to readers of Rural Delivery, explores these topics in depth in relation to the forest industry in Maine in The Double Bottom Line: Managing Maine’s Forests to Increase Carbon Sequestration and Decrease Carbon (April 2016).
Download Full text (36 pages docx) | View Summary
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, clearcuts, Climate Change | Leave a comment

Editorials and letters about forestry in Nova Scotia, continued..4Jan017

Higgins Mt., Cumberland Co. 2011.  width=

Clearcut at Higgins Mt., Cumberland Co. 2011.
They were looking for spring wildflowers in the Acadian forest, not clearcuts!
Click on photo for video.

NUMBERS vs EYES December 27, 2016 in the CH, a letter writer from Wentworth Station: “Regarding recent letters on forestry, methinks industry reps and the Department of Natural Resources do protest too much. They throw a lot of numbers and statistics at us, believing we ordinary citizens will believe their weak justifications for continued clear-cutting, whole-tree harvesting and destructive practices. It takes only a short drive in any rural area of Nova Scotia to see forests continue to be cut and destroyed at an alarming, unsustainable rate…” Continue reading

Posted in clearcuts, Letters&Editorials, NSDNR | Leave a comment

Natural Resources Canada GHG Calculator confirms Nova Scotia forest bioenergy schemes are worse than coal

Sample output from GHG calculator

Sample output from GHG calculator.
Click on image for larger version.

Just under a year ago a Press Release from NSP (Nova Scotia Power) indicated NSP planned to increase the proportion of electricity derived from biomass to 7% of the total, up from 2.8% in 2015, while reducing use of fossil fuels. Most of this would come from clearcutting living trees, including whole tree clearcuts, rather than from forestry and sawmill wastes.

NSP has “an obligation to its ratepayers to get wood fibre as cheaply as possible” and “the cheapest way is to clear land, not selectively harvest to improve the lot for the future.” – NSDNR Associate Deputy Director Deputy Minister Alan Eddy in The Coast (April 16, 2016)

Continue reading

Posted in Biomass, clearcuts, Climate Change, NSDNR, Show Us the Science | 1 Comment

How old are old Halifax oaks?

imgp5534statelyoaksHalifax hosts some magnificent red oaks, readily distinguished at a distance in winter by their distinctive gnarly profiles. When I see one cut down, I like to count the rings and have been surprised at the relatively young age of quite large trees. Several cut trees 2.5-3 ft wide (76-91 cm) I have looked at over past years were barely over or were under 100 years old.
Continue reading

Posted in Natural History, Urban forest | Leave a comment