Feedback sought on CCFM’s A Vision for Canada’s Forests: 2018 and Beyond

This message from Julie Towers, Deputy Minister, NSNDR has been circulating:

“The Canadian Council of Forest Ministers (CCFM) is an important forum for the respective governments across Canada to discuss issues, exchange information, work cooperatively, provide leadership and generate actions on forestry related matters of interests to all Canadians.

“Our national vision for forests was last updated in 2008. Because you live, work, play and reflect in our forest ecosystems, we need your help to establish common aspirational goals for sustainable forest stewardship, to increase awareness of Canada’s forest management practices and to promote collaborative action.
Continue reading

Posted in Social Values | Comments Off on Feedback sought on CCFM’s A Vision for Canada’s Forests: 2018 and Beyond

SMU Prof doesn’t think carbon offsets work but a recent analysis of the California carbon credits market suggests they do work

We need open, honest, non-personalized and non-politicized discussion of forest GHGs

Two approaches to forest management in Nova Scotia: LEFT: even aged management/short rotations. RIGHT: Selective harvesting, high standing volume and structural integrity is maintained. The latter but not the former would be eligible for carbon offset credits, which could make it the more attractive option for many small woodlot owners in NS, especially those with high volume/older forest stands.

CBC made a post based on a CBC Info Morning interview with Dale Prest: Carbon offsetting could preserve N.S. forests, but researchers raise concerns CBC, May 7, 2018.

The interview with Dale Prest was also the focus of post on nsforestnotes.ca a few days ago: Dale Prest on “Climate Forests” (Post, May 4, 2018).

The CBC post highlights the main points made by Dale Prest including Prest’s contention that when it comes to forests carbon offsets, Nova Scotia has some key advantages compared to Ontario and BC.

CBC also talked to Saint Mary’s University professor Kate Ervine who is critical of the concept of offsets. “She said the main issue with carbon offsetting is that it doesn’t address the principal source of additional carbon dioxide in the atmosphere: burning fossil fuels…They don’t actually lower their emissions, they’ve bought a credit.”
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, Climate Change | Comments Off on SMU Prof doesn’t think carbon offsets work but a recent analysis of the California carbon credits market suggests they do work

Letters, Op-eds and news items May 1-5, 2018

On clearcutting, The Mill, biomass and carbon emissions, and politicans tripping over themseleves on environmental issues

There has been a steady stream of letters, op-eds, news items related to forests and forestry over the past week.

It’s hard to keep up with sometimes, but Mike Parker covers most of it in his Woods and Waters Nova Scotia (Facebook) posts, so I regularly check those out to see what I might have missed. Mike also mediates a civilized discussion of his posts, often newsy in themselves.

Here are some Letters, Op-eds and news items from the past week, for the record.
Continue reading

Posted in Biomass, clearcuts, Climate Change, Conservation, Independent Review, Pulp & Paper | Comments Off on Letters, Op-eds and news items May 1-5, 2018

NS Legislature’s Resource Committee Thurs 24 May 2018: Current State and Future of the Forestry Industry in Nova Scotia

WestFor will be a witness and the Report of the Independent Review of Forestry Practices should be in, so it could be the first open-to-the-public discussion of the recommendations related to the Western Crown Lands

The Nova Scotia Legislature’s Standing Committee on Resources is holding a session on “Current State and Future of the Forestry Industry in Nova Scotia” on May 24, 2018, 10am-12pm. View Standing Committees/Resources.

Currently (May 5), under the “Witness / Agenda” heading, only the topic is listed; no witnesses are cited.
UPDATE (May 21): Witnesses are now listed: WestFor Management Inc. – Marcus Zwicker, General Manager & Forest Nova Scotia – Jeff Bishop, Executive Director

I have been told but have not independently confirmed that WestFor – the consortium of 13 mills granted licenses to harvest wood in the Western Crown Lands – will be one of the groups/individuals giving testimony & answering questions. At the last of the Committee on Resources’s monthly meetings in which forestry issues were discussed (Forest Management on Private Lands, Thursday, December 7, 2017), April 19th, 2018 was set as a tentative date for WestFor to appear before the Committee on Resources; there is no record of such a meeting, so the info I got about WestFor appearing on May 24 is probably correct.
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, NSDNR, Show Us the Science, WestFor | Comments Off on NS Legislature’s Resource Committee Thurs 24 May 2018: Current State and Future of the Forestry Industry in Nova Scotia

Dale Prest on “Climate Forests”

The sooner The Climate Forest Company can get going in Nova Scotia the better it will be for our forests, small woodlot owners and our climate

Two approaches to forest management in Nova Scotia: LEFT: even aged management/short rotations. RIGHT: Selective harvesting, high standing volume and structural integrity is maintained. The latter but not the former would be eligible for carbon offset credits, which could make it the more attractive option for many small woodlot owners in NS, especially those with high volume/older forest stands.

UPDATE May 8, 2018: CBC made a post based on its CBC Info Morning interview with Dale Prest (also cited in this post). CBC also talked to Saint Mary’s University professor Kate Ervine who is critical of the concept of offsets. “She said the main issue with carbon offsetting is that it doesn’t address the principal source of additional carbon dioxide in the atmosphere: burning fossil fuels.”  View Carbon offsetting could preserve N.S. forests, but researchers raise concerns CBC, May 7, 2018.

———————————————–

I was lucky enough to catch an interview with Dale Prest on CBC’s Information Morning yesterday morning, on the topic of “Climate Forests”. This followed my making a post on the topic of carbon offsets a couple of days before.

As I listened to Dale, I realized I had erred in some of my interpretation of how forest carbon offsets work. I made a few changes and asked Dale via e-mail if I now had it right. He replied yes, and that I could be forgiven for the initial error as “no one has figured out how to structure payments for small family woodlot owners”.

Dale, however, has been a key player in the development of Community Forest International’s successful foray into forest carbon credits via a project on a 705 acre woodlot on Whaelghinbran Farm near Sussex, N.B. – Dale said in the interview that it’s the only place east of British Columbia where a project of this nature has successfully launched and sold.
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, Climate Change, Conservation, Independent Review | Comments Off on Dale Prest on “Climate Forests”

“Smartphone App Enables Family Forest Owners to Get Paid to Store Carbon” – but not in Nova Scotia (yet)

And some thoughts on the impacts on wood markets if Nova Scotian woodlot owners could benefit from carbon markets

Addendum May 3, 2018: Listening to Dale Prest on CBC this morning, I realized I had not done my homework properly. Apologies to readers. It is not just the high volume stands that can benefit from carbon offset credits (as implied in the post originally – that has been corrected) but the  high volume stands would  be the most valuable.  Any management program that would increase the carbon stored on a property would in principle be eligible for carbon offset credits; as more carbon is stored the $ return increases, so the higher the volume initially, the higher the return initially*. A 100 year commitment is required. There is a lot more involved. Currently there is no system in place in Nova Scotia to facilitate woodlot owners participating in carbon markets. Dale Prest is heading up the recently formed Climate Forest Company which will assist Maritime woodlot owners seeking to participate in carbon markets. Some further notes and links on forest carbon offsets are appended at the end of this post.
_________________
*I checked with Dale Prest on the accuracy of this statement (“as more carbon is stored the $ return increases, so the higher the volume initially, the higher the return initially”). He says it “is indeed accurate, as those with more carbon will be able to sell more carbon credits and realize higher returns both initially and throughout the life of the project.” He also commented:”No one has figured out how to structure payments for small family woodlot owners. Money is trading hands using the Forest Carbon Works system so obviously they have a lot figured out, however no harvesting is allowed in those forests, an important caveat to some. [Last sentence edited May 4, 2018]. The only projects that have been developed are on large land bases owned by single individuals, which is considerably more straight forward.” The Climate Forest Company is developing/promoting a system that would allow smaller woodlot owners in the Maritimes to participate in carbon markets.
————————

Merchantable forest volumes in sections of eastern NS (above) and southwest NS (below) After centuries of intensive harvesting, high volume forests stands now exist only as a patchwork throughout the province. The darker patches in the maps above have the higher volumes that store the most carbon and that would be most valuable to woodlot owners participating in carbon markets under an expanded Cap and Trade system for Nova Scotia. High volume stands are most abundant in SW Nova Scotia, now the focus (or desired focus) of industrial forest harvesting in Nova Scotia.
Click on image for larger version

Begin post of May 1, 2018: Nova Scotia introduced its Cap and Trade Legislation on Sep 29, 2017; it was given Royal Assent on Oct 26, 2017. The system is restricted to the province of Nova Scotia and has no provisions that would enable private woodlot owners to benefit from carbon offsets* as promoted by Dale Prest:

“Prest says the province needs to implement the right cap-and-trade system, one that openly trades with markets in Ontario, Quebec and California. But the province has initially committed to creating their own system, with all the trading done within Nova Scotia, although they’re open to options.”

Prest believes that major financial benefits for woodlot owners and rural communities could be realized and that opening the market up would prompt a move “From one [a forest industry] that rewards a low cost of production that results in clear cutting, to one that rewards maintaining and growing a healthy forest as possible.” – in Cap-and-trade system could help province’s forestry industry by Amanda Panacci for Chronicle Herald Nov 23, 2017

Continue reading

Posted in clearcuts, Climate Change, Conservation, Economics, Independent Review, Private Woodlots, WestFor, Woodscamp | Comments Off on “Smartphone App Enables Family Forest Owners to Get Paid to Store Carbon” – but not in Nova Scotia (yet)

Apr 30, 2018: Report from Independent Review of Forestry Practices in Nova Scotia delayed but will be released publicly when ready

From NSDNR Press Release, April 30, 2018:

University of King’s College president Bill Lahey has informed Natural Resources Minister Margaret Miller that although he will be completing his report on forest practices in the next few days, he is subjecting it to further review by advisors in international law and forestry economics before he finalizes his report for submission to the minister and public release.

Prof. Lahey will finalize his report once he has this input. He will then submit it to the minister and make it available to the public.
Continue reading

Posted in Independent Review | Comments Off on Apr 30, 2018: Report from Independent Review of Forestry Practices in Nova Scotia delayed but will be released publicly when ready

Nova Scotia government brags about its Class 2 EA for Boat Harbour cleanup further defying the logic for a class 1 EA for The Pipe

UPDATE Apr 30, 2018: How fishers feel about the Pipe: OPINION: Pulp pipe puts fishery livelihoods on the line by Krista Fulton, Apr 28, 2018 in the Chronicle Herald

YESTERDAY
TODAY: Environmental Racism is no longer acceptable

On Friday, Apr 27, 2018 Environment Minister Iain Rankin announced in a Press Release that the process for cleanup of the Boat Harbour Treatment facility which must cease operation by Jan 31, 2020, will be subject to a Type II Environmental Assessment.

Thus the government is setting more stringent requirements for cleaning up historical pollution than the same government set just under a year ago as appropriate to assess the future processing of the same pollutants and release of the products directly into the Northumerland Strait via The Pipe.

The logical contradiction did not escape the notice of Pictou Landing First Nation Chief Andrea Paul:
Continue reading

Posted in Pulp & Paper | Comments Off on Nova Scotia government brags about its Class 2 EA for Boat Harbour cleanup further defying the logic for a class 1 EA for The Pipe

Northern Pulp makes its too-big-to-fail case and I wonder about “Sponsored Content” in the Chronicle Herald

I guess “Sponsored Content” is not “fake news”, but it can detract from otherwise good journalism in mainstream newspapers & news magazines, especially in the online versions

UPDATE Apr 26, 2018.
The Chronicle Herald responds to questions
—————-

Map with features on a map posted on a Northern Pulp website. “Our proposal is to construct an Effluent Treatment Facility on land at the mill property, and lay a pipeline on the bottom of Pictou Harbour…

Northern Pulp has used a “Sponsored Content” feature offered by the Chronicle Herald to tell Nova Scotians how very important it is to the province.

View Nova Scotia pulp and paper industry continues to flourish
Sponsored Content – Northern Pulp, Chronicle Herald Apr 24, 2018*.
_______________________
*No date of publication is given; the date cited is the date I viewed it.
Continue reading

Posted in Economics, Pulp & Paper, Show Us the Science, Social Values | Comments Off on Northern Pulp makes its too-big-to-fail case and I wonder about “Sponsored Content” in the Chronicle Herald

Nova Scotia’s Tidewater Pipe Impasse, continued (Apr 23, 2018)

Map with features on a map posted on a Northern Pulp website. “Our proposal is to construct an Effluent Treatment Facility on land at the mill property, and lay a pipeline on the bottom of Pictou Harbour…

It would be only 10 km or less, but many of the issues applying to Kinder Morgan’s Trans Mountain get-Alberta-oil-to-tidewater pipeline – Environment, Jobs, First Nations, different provincial jurisdictions, a government/industry agenda backed up by EAs, real or perceived deadlines and firmly held, mutually incompatible desired outcomes by people directly affected apply also to “The Pipe“.

And like the Kinder Morgan pipeline, the government most directly involved seems frozen in time while the clock ticks, and any “solution” the government might devise, mostly to satisfy itself that it has addressed both sides of the issue, would involve a huge expenditure of public funds.

Todays chapter: public release of the letter the Northumberland Fishermen’s Association wrote to Nova Scotia MLAs asking them “to honestly consider what is at risk from Northern Pulp’s proposal [and] not to make another costly mistake.”

View OPINION: Fishermen ask MLAs to avoid another costly mistake with Northern Pulp effluent
by Ronald Heighton (President, Northumberland Fishermen’s Association) in the Chronicle Herald, Apr 23, 2018.
Continue reading

Posted in Pulp & Paper | Comments Off on Nova Scotia’s Tidewater Pipe Impasse, continued (Apr 23, 2018)