Logging at Nova Scotia’s Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes Crown land delayed by company doing the cut to respect Migratory Bird Convention Act 11Jun2019

WestFor was scheduled to resume logging on Corbett-Dalhousie Lake Forest on June 9, 2019

UPDATE June 12, 2019: My report of yesterday (below) is likely not completely accurate. On CBC AM this morning (7:20 am June 12, 2019) : WestFor’s Marcus Zwicker says all across Canada, logging continues though nesting seasons; especially those on the front line in NS, he says, where a nesting bird, an owl, anything that can be identified is seen they will bring in experts as necessary and make adjustments (but not stop harvesting); he denies they contravene the MBCA…However, on further questioning, Mr. Zwicker said “it would be inevitable that nests are destroyed”. I tried to reach Stephen Saunders of Valliside Forestry this a.m. to clarify whether his statement as reported by CTV that ‘logging at Corbett-Dalhosuie Lakes would not be starting until later in the summer and that they follow strict guidelines’ meant they are respecting the Migratory Birds Convention Act; he was “in the woods” and not available at the time. Mr. Zwicker said the delay at Corbett-Dalhousie lake was related to weather, not to concerns about nesting birds. It’s all about balance he says. He said that they did change some harvesting plans during the past winter to accommodate recreational snowmobilers.
Also:
N.S. logging firm says concern for birds must be balanced against industry needs
By Michael Tutton, THE CANADIAN PRESS on CTV news, June 11, 2019
Turned down – Forestry minister Rankin rejects Annapolis County bid to preserve old growth forest
Lawrence Powell on www.trurodaily.com June 11, 2019

————-
Original Post (June 11, 2019)

This appears to be the first time that a logging operation on Crown land has been delayed in order to respect the Migratory Bird Convention Act

According to a report on CTV News for Monday June 10 2019 (19min:21sec-20:34)

A peaceful protest is continuing outside of Bridgetown in the Annapolis Valley…Naturalists arrived at the site yesterday [Sunday] and camped out overnight. They are concerned about logging in the area which could disrupt migratory birds in and around West Dalhousie, also concerned about losing Old growth Forest and they intend to take steps to disrupt those operations…

“Its time the province listens to the people…People simply don’t support cuts like these in the midst of a climate crisis…Its also about what’s happening all over NS”…

A sign went up last week from WestFor saying cutting would resume as early as today… One wildlife biologist said he has called police and Environment Canada to enforce provisions of the Migratory Bird Convention Act. The company says they follow strict guidelines and the cut hasn’t started yet and it won’t start until sometime this summer*.
__________
*May 11, evening: It has been pointed out to me that this does not necessarily mean that the apparent delay is related to the Migratory Bird Convention Act.

Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, Conservation, Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes, Social Media, WestFor | Comments Off on Logging at Nova Scotia’s Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes Crown land delayed by company doing the cut to respect Migratory Bird Convention Act 11Jun2019

Nova Scotia’s Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes Crown land scheduled to be harvested in nesting season, endangered turtle found in the lakes 5Jun2019

Updates June 9, 2019
Extinction Rebellion at Corbett/Dalhousie
Posted on Annapolis Royal & Area – Environment & Ecology by Sue ES “Approximately 50 people there with Xtinction Rebellion”
CHIMNEY SWIFTS AT CORBETT-DALHOUSIE LAKE FOREST
As of this morning, we have now CONFIRMED at least ***FOUR*** CHIMNEY SWIFTS on territory at the Hardwood forest at Corbett-Dalhousie lake — confirmed by 4 experienced birders (one beingn a noted avian researcher) – visual and sound – on THREE CONSECUTIVE DAYS in the very same small area over the Hardwood part of the forest. Confirmed again this very morning by 2 experienced birders. I provide a link to the COSEWIC website where it Chimney Swifts are listed as Schedule 1: Threatened on the SARA list.
www. wildlife-species.canada.ca – Home> Species at risk public registry> Species List> Chimney Swift

Scott Leslie drone photo June 7, 2019
Click on photo for larger version

Updates June 7&8, 2019:
Drone photos by Scott Leslie
Post by Bev Wigney on Annapolis Royal & Area – Environment & Ecology, drone photos by Scott Leslie
Naturalists comb Nova Scotia woods for birds in bid to halt loggers
THE CANADIAN PRESS ON CTV NEWS “Naturalists are listening for and spotting migratory song birds — including an endangered species — in an effort to halt logging of a Nova Scotia forest containing old hardwoods…Scott Leslie, the author of seven books on natural history, said Friday evening he spotted or heard over a dozen species in the area that faces harvesting, including Chimney Swifts, which are listed as an endangered species in Nova Scotia.”
– Call to end logging during migratory bird nesting season (audio)
CBC Info AM. “Christine Curry says no logging should be allowed during migratory bird nesting season; the birds should be protected by the Migratory Bird Convention Act.” Environmental Lawyer Jamie Simpson is also interviewed about why the Migratory Birds Act is not being adhered to by forestry operations in NS.
List of birds
Posted on NatureNS by Bev Wigney June 8, 2019

———–

Original Post, June 5, 2019

A post by Annapolis area naturalist Bev Wigney On Annapolis Royal & Area – Environment & Ecology this a.m.(bolding mine)

LETTER — JUST SENT:

WestFor begins new logging on Corbett-Dalhousie Lake Forest on June 9, 2019

Serious situation at Corbett-Dalhousie Lake – several inappropriate actions
Honourable Premier Stephen McNeil,
We have a serious situation here at Corbett-Dalhousie Lake Forest. As you know, Annapolis County recently passed a motion respectfully requesting the province to “dedicate the Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes property to the Municipality of the County of Annapolis to develop and manage a climate forest and demonstrate a new economy based on ecological forestry management that will increase local jobs, community recreation and tourism.” (May 21, 2019). At that time, the County also asked that no further harvest operations be carried out while their request was under consideration.
As of yesterday, a notification sign has been posted at the property — by Westfor — saying that work is expected to commence on June 9th. This is *not* an appropriate response to our County’s request.
Continue reading

Posted in Conservation, Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes, L&F, Show Us the Science, WestFor | Comments Off on Nova Scotia’s Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes Crown land scheduled to be harvested in nesting season, endangered turtle found in the lakes 5Jun2019

Nova Scotia Lands & Forestry makes a few announcements 31May 2019

In 2010, Forestry Minister promises “There’s gonna be a reduction in clearcutting in Nova Scotia”. In 2019, Forestry minister promises ‘dramatic reduction’ in clear cutting. New ETA: 2020. “I’ll believe it when I see it”, says one.

L&F Minister Iain Rankin talked to CBC’s Michael Gorman, reported May 30, 2019 (“Forestry minister promises ‘dramatic reduction’ in clear cutting“). Key points as reported by Gorman (bolding mine):

– Lands and Forestry Minister Iain Rankin says there will be a “drastic reduction” in clear cutting once Nova Scotia’s new forest management guide is complete, something he expects will happen by late November or early December.

Rankin said people who participated in the process to develop Lahey’s report will soon be receiving invitations for a June meeting with the minister and his staff to learn more about what’s been done to date.
Continue reading

Posted in Ind Rev Post-Report, L&F | Comments Off on Nova Scotia Lands & Forestry makes a few announcements 31May 2019

Bev Wigney On Forest Roads in Nova Scotia 29May2019

Bev Wigney is an Annapolis area naturalist concerned about the state of our forests. She posted this ‘Sunday morning rant’ on Forest Roads on the Facebook page for Annapolis Royal & Area – Environment & Ecology, a public Facebook group, on May 26, 2019.

In the ongoing controversies over logging, and about clearcutting in particular in NS, we don’t hear much about the impacts of forest roads. Bev raises some really critical issues so I asked for her permission to re-post her comments on NSFN. Extraction trails are also problematical, discussed in a subsequent post by Bev W., copied in part below.

———-
Continue reading

Posted in Conservation, Landscape Level Planning, Tree Harvests | Comments Off on Bev Wigney On Forest Roads in Nova Scotia 29May2019

Nova Scotia Annapolis County Council seeks protection for Corbett-Dalhousie Lake Forest as a “Climate Forest” 27May2019

Signs of a healthy, old forest at Corbett-Dalhousie Lake

The Annapolis County Council’s letter to the Premier requesting an out from the Westfor deal played a pivotal role in the emergence of the Independent Review of Forest Practices in Nova Scotia which was announced by the Liberal Government just before the 2017 election.

Now the Council has written to government requesting that it follow through on several key recommendations of that review  by putting a “an immediate hold on all harvest operations, underway or anticipated, in the Corbett-Dalhousie parcels” and requests the province

…to dedicate the Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes property to the Municipality of the County of Annapolis to develop and manage a climate forest and demonstrate a new economy based on ecological forestry management that will increase local jobs, community recreation and tourism.

View the full letter posted on the Facebook site for Annapolis Royal & Area – Environment & Ecology, or view the text reproduced below.

View Climate forest proposed – Annapolis County wants chance to develop new ecologically managed economic model
Lawrence Powell in www.annapoliscountyspectator.ca, May 23, 2019

Thanks, Annapolis County Council and Annapolis County residents, for speaking up for all species of Nova Scotia
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, Citizen Science, Climate Change, Conservation, Ind Rev Post-Report, L&F, Social Media, WestFor | Comments Off on Nova Scotia Annapolis County Council seeks protection for Corbett-Dalhousie Lake Forest as a “Climate Forest” 27May2019

Some upbeat thoughts on the International Day for Biological Diversity 22May2019

Shadbush (Amelanchier arborea) in bloom on May 22, 2011

UPDATE May 22, 2019 evening – Positive news begets positive news. Prof David Garbary of StFX sent me this message:

I just saw your recent Forest Notes contribution. Here is another positive bit of biodiversity news from the marine environment. I (with Carolyn Bird, Herb Vandermeulen and Beverly Hymes) just published a paper on macroalgal biodiversity of Brier Island (Proc. N.S. Inst. Sci). In the summer of 2017 we identified over 150 species from the island mostly associated with the metaphorical ‘forests’ of intertidal fucoids and kelp beds. This was slightly more species than a 1970 paper out of NRC for the whole of Digby Neck with collections over a whole year.

Thx David G.
——–
I wouldn’t have been aware that today is the The International Day For Biological Diversity, except for some posts by Bev Wigney on Annapolis Royal & Area – Environment & Ecology (a public Facebook group).

It’s a day we should really stop and celebrate what we have, amidst the otherwise almost endless bad news about climate, environment and biodiversity generally.

So to celebrate a bit, following are some articles of the last few days expressing mostly upbeat thoughts on the topic.
Continue reading

Posted in Biophilia, Conservation | Comments Off on Some upbeat thoughts on the International Day for Biological Diversity 22May2019

iNaturalist keeping an eye on Nova Scotia’s forests 21May2019

Citizen science comes of age in NS forests

Annapolis area naturalist/forest activist Bev Wigney established the first – to my knowledge – iNaturalist Place and Project for a Nova Scotia Crown Land forest subject to logging

It didn’t make national or international news, but Halifax did really well in the recent City Nature Challenge (April 26-29, 2019):

And… the final results are in: Halifax, we did amazing! 7647 observations of Nature representing 911 species in FOUR DAYS!

Mary Kennedy was our top observer (630) and Ben Armstrong observed the most species (163). Together, we were a team of 237 participants (plus all those represented by families or school groups). Overall, Halifax ranked in the Top 50 (of 159 cities) across all categories, and when you weight for climate (latitude) we ranked in the Top 3!

Continue reading

Posted in Citizen Science, Conservation, Show Us the Science, Social Media | Comments Off on iNaturalist keeping an eye on Nova Scotia’s forests 21May2019

Intensive tree cull in Halifax’s Point Pleasant Park delayed until after nesting season; Nova Scotia L&F continues to ignore federal regs 12May2019

View of the entrance to Halifax Harbour across Point Pleasant Park. The area in the foreground was completely stripped by Hurricane Juan in 2003. White Pine at right was a survivor. May 5, 2017

“We don’t want to disturb those nests — and the regulations stipulate that we can’t” – but there is no such compliance on provincially administered Crown lands

It was International Migratory Birds Day on Sat May 11.  Appropriately, although coincidentally,  it was announced the day before that “A plan to cut down 80,000 trees inside Halifax’s most popular seaside park has been put on hold until the fall to protect the nests of many species of birds,” (Canadian Press/CTV News May 10, 2019). That decision followed concerns expressed by birdwatchers.

Earlier this week, city officials said the cutting at Point Pleasant Park, which is aimed at restoring the health of the park’s Acadian forest, would be carried out in June and July.

However, spokesman Brendan Elliott confirmed Friday no trees would be felled until September because an earlier cull would have violated federal regulations pertaining to migratory birds.
Continue reading

Posted in Conservation, L&F, Parks & Protected Areas | Comments Off on Intensive tree cull in Halifax’s Point Pleasant Park delayed until after nesting season; Nova Scotia L&F continues to ignore federal regs 12May2019

Nova Scotia Lands & Forestry developing a communication plan 9May2019

UPDATE MAY 11, 2019: For a far more informative article on this topic, view Truth Be Told: Nova Scotia’s forest department hires a PR firm with forest industry ties to help it with transparency by Linda Pannozzo in the Halifax Examiner, May 10, 2019. It discloses the firm of the consultants, and provides some details on issues with the Harvest Map Viewer (re: “How do you think the HPMV could be improved?: cited below) that I was not familiar with but are pretty critical; also it references the recommendations of the Natural Resources Strategy regarding communication. Well worth the $10 for a month’s subscription to get access to the full article if you are following this topic. I hope L&F and the Consultants developing the communication plan can afford it because they could definitely benefit from reading it.
Continue reading

Posted in Ind Rev Post-Report, L&F | Comments Off on Nova Scotia Lands & Forestry developing a communication plan 9May2019

Annapolis Co. group finds fresh stump of 138 yr old tree in Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes Forest, but it’s not Old Growth says L&F 6May2019

Stump of 138 yr old beech (left) and a remaining 32″ dbh Yellow Birch, flagged with wide yellow “CAUTION” tape “so that the foresters would not “accidentally” fell these trees”

UPDATE May 27, 2019: The 35% Question (Facebook Post)
“Last Thursday, I received a reply from Forestry Maps (no human name attached to the email) answering some questions I had posed to them over the previous weeks. One answer in particular bothers me. I asked about the statement made by both Min. Iain Rankin, and Westfor’s Marcus Zwicker – on CBC Information Morning – that only around 35 percent of the trees in the stand would be removed. Okay, since then, I was told that that percentage doesn’t include the trees that have to be cut down to make extraction lanes through the forest to access what are called the “leave strips”. To make an extraction lane, you have to remove all of the trees so that you have a “lane” to drive in with the equipment. Everyone who has been out to Corbett-Dalhousie Lake Forest knows what these look like — they are wide “lanes” running side by side into the forest — going east west up to the 20 meter buffer zone along the lake shoreline.
So, all the trees cut down to make those lanes are not counted in the harvest. Nor are the trees cut down to make the big road down the center of the peninsula – 750 metres in in length and probably about 30 metres or more across (the trees cut down, I mean). The “leave strips” are no wider than the extraction lanes — in fact, I think they would be a little less. I should bring my measuring tape and check that next time I go. We are told the loggers remove “around 35 percent” of the trees that are still standing in these “leave strips” so those are the “around 35 percent” of the trees that Rankin and Zwicker are referring to when they say that it is a “partial” or “individual tree selection” cut. I’ll post Forestry Maps explanation of this below – and below that, I’ve posted my reply to them… (read post for more)

UPDATES May 23, 2019:
‘Stop the Chop’ – Extinction Rebellion on standby to halt Corbett Lake Crown forest harvest
Lawrence Powell in www.annapoliscountyspectator.ca, May 23, 2019
XR Forest Protectors on Rick Howe Show on May 23, 2019
YouTube recording, Nina Newington talking about the Corbett-Dalhousie Lake forest
Climate forest proposed – Annapolis County wants chance to develop new ecologically managed economic model
Lawrence Powell in www.annapoliscountyspectator.ca, May 23, 2019 ” Annapolis County wants the province to hand over a swath of Crown forest south of Bridgetown so the municipality can develop and manage a climate forest and demonstrate that a new economic model based on ecological forestry management can increase local jobs, community recreation, and tourism.
They passed the motion May 21 and have drafted a letter to Department of Lands and Forestry Minister Iain Rankin with the request. Currently WestFor has the option to harvest the forest in question and some of that work began last year.”

UPDATES May 22, 2019:
Annapolis Co. Council writes Hon. Iain Rankin, Minister Department of Lands and Forestry: ““It is hereby recommended that the Municipality of the County of Annapolis respectfully request the Province of Nova Scotia to dedicate the Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes property to the Municipality of the County of Annapolis to develop and manage a climate forest and demonstrate a new economy based on ecological forestry management that will increase local jobs, community recreation and tourism.”
Press Release: Action to protect the Corbett – Dalhousie Lake forest
By Nova Scotia Advocate – May 18, 2019

UPDATE May 21, 2019: iNaturalist keeping an eye on Nova Scotia’s forests 21May2019
Post on NSFN. “Annapolis area naturalist/forest activist Bev Wigney established the first – to my knowledge – iNaturalist Place and Project for a Nova Scotia Crown Land forest subject to logging”
Continue reading

Posted in Acadian Forest, L&F, Old Growth, Social Media | Comments Off on Annapolis Co. group finds fresh stump of 138 yr old tree in Corbett-Dalhousie Lakes Forest, but it’s not Old Growth says L&F 6May2019